Exchange Bar and Grill is reader-supported. When you buy through a link on this page, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

The Green Mountain Grills vs. Traeger

In the past few years, there has been an open dispute among grill manufacturers about grill products. E

veryone has wondered which product is better for pellet grilling — whether it’s the Green Mountain Grills or the Traeger ones. If you do your research when choosing a reliable pellet grill, you will see that both brands are on top.

So, who is the winner in the ultimate battle? Green Mountain Grills or Traeger? And how do you choose the best pellet grill for your needs?

Below, we share our full overview of a GMG and Traeger model to help you find a brand that meets your needs.

Green Mountain Grills vs. Traeger

Listing the main features of both grills is easy. But different people have different needs. So it is better to read the details below and find which brand is right for your needs and budget.

Let’s move on to the main features of GMG Davy Crockett and Traeger Pro 575.

GMG Davy Crockett

Small, portable, and lightweight — these are some of the keywords to describe the GMG Davy Crockett pellet grill that is perfect for yard barbecuing or camping.

The model comes in multiple design options. It boasts sturdy and multi-functional legs that you can fold up or use as handles when transporting the grill. GMG Davy Crockett is perfect for campers, tailgaters, and people with RVs who prefer cooking outside.

Another feature worth mentioning is the Wi-Fi system that enables you to control the temperature and monitor the grilling process from your smartphone. The Server Mode allows you to connect to the grill (via phone or tablet) and keep an eye on it, even if you are away.

Traeger Pro 575

The Traeger Pro Series is among the best-selling pellet grills on the market. This Pro 575 model is no exception. With a simple design and plenty of nifty features, this model differs from the other models because of its built-in WiFIRE technology.

The Traeger Pro 575 supports remote operations. You can adjust the grill from your smartphone or tablet and keep an eye on your BBQ. Another great thing about the Traeger grill is its D2 drivetrain feature. 

This Pro Series pellet grill starts quicker, heats faster, and delivers better smoke quality. The result is an unmatched wood-fired flavor anytime you roast.

Features Face-to-Face

Green Mountain Grills offers a smaller grilling area than Traeger grills. When compared to Traeger, we find that the latter has a slightly smaller grilling area of 418 square inches.

Let’s look more in-depth at the Davy Crockett by Green Mountain Grills and the Trager Pro 575.  

Brand History

As the first pellet smoker manufacturer, no other grill company has a history as vast as Traeger. In 1985, they invented pellet grills, but at that time, the brand failed to provide its customers with high-quality products.

The design of their pellet grills hasn’t changed much. Almost all of their models maintain the classic grill design. But the Traeger brand is devoted to everything they do. Each new model they make is top quality, and this shows through their sales.

Soon after the Traeger patent expired (in 2008), another company started making pellet grills. The company is Green Mountain Grills — a brand known as Traeger’s biggest competitor.

Today, GMG is one of the most recognizable brands of pellet smokers. They offer modern designs at competitive prices. Despite being new to the market, GMG’s strategy revolved around low prices. Since 2014, they have been dominating the grill market with modern grills at affordable prices.

If Traeger was the creator of the pellet grills, Green Mountain Grills is responsible for the Wi-Fi feature found in pellet grills. Both brands now include Wi-Fi on their models, but GMG still wins in terms of better design and features.

Price Comparison: Which Grill Is Cheaper?

Between the two brands, Green Mountain Grills has cheaper models. And there are a variety of GMG models from which to choose. The Davy Crockett model is a portable and lightweight pellet, grill giving it excellent mobility at an affordable price.

All Traeger models cost more than GMG or other pellet grill manufacturers. Despite their high prices, Traeger models are basic and don’t offer anything extra for their “premium” aspect.

Their attempt to keep up with the latest technology and the innovative solutions in their newest models still fails to deliver a reasonable price, especially when compared to other top-quality manufacturers on the market.

Temperature Range

One of the best things about pellet grilling is that it allows you to set the temperature according to your needs.

GMG is, without a doubt, the leader when it comes to temperature range and searing ability. The Davy Crockett grills have a more extensive temperature range, from 150 degrees to 550 degrees with 5-degree increment controls. The Traeger Pro 575’s highest temperature setting of 500 degrees almost matches the Davy Crockett.

Green Mountain Grills also has better heat retention, which adds more value to the brand. One of the GMG’s temperature secrets lies in the Sense-Mate. This sensor monitors the grill temperature and makes adjustments for you. The feature gives GMG extra points in the Green Mountain Grills vs. Traeger race.

Build Quality

In terms of workmanship quality, both brands have something to offer.

At first glance, Green Mountain Grills are better. GMG pays attention to design and build quality and composition — all of which make them innovators in this race. But GMG models are slightly cheaper than Traeger Pro 575 and other models.

On the other hand, Traeger claims that quality is what drives the brand forward. Within the last few years, there have been some comments about the decreasing quality of Traeger pellet grills. They’ve stuck to the same old design and models for years, but you can tell that their build quality has improved.

So, while GMG has excellent design and composition, Traeger is a simpler option with consistent quality over the years.

Pellet Hopper

Both Green Mountain Grills and Traeger provide pellet containers that match the grill size. You can rest easy knowing the full box each grill holds is enough for cooking and smoking without the need to refuel.

GMG’s pellet hopper features a pellet-view window so you can keep an eye out for when your grill is low on pellets.

Mobility

In general, Green Mountain Grills have portable designs, and Davy Crockett is the right example in this category. Its compact size makes it perfect for transportation. You can take the grill to your RV, tailgate, or put it in your truck when you travel.

Even though Traeger is not as small or lightweight as its competitor, it will meet the expectations of adventurers who prefer to cook outside at home.

Warranty

When it comes to pellet grills, a three-year warranty is one of the most popular options. And both Traeger and Green Mountain Grills offer the three-year warranty for their pellet smokers.

For the smaller GMG models, such a warranty is solid. But when it comes to expensive Traeger models, customers usually expect at least a five-year warranty.

Accessories

Another feature making Green Mountain Grills superior is the stainless-steel grate feature. The impressive characteristic of these grates is that they resist corrosion and rust.

The Sense-Mate air sensor is a helpful addition to the grill set. The sensor puts the pellet grill in Turbo Mode and helps it start faster, no matter the outside temperature.

The peaked lid is another useful accessory. It offers more cooking space to help you prepare both small and large feasts.

What makes Traeger Pro 575 stand out from other models on the market is its main (bottom) and its secondary (top) rack that separates food when cooking. The model comes with an electronic ignition system and a digital controller, making temperature adjustments a super-easy and convenient process.

Style

The GMG grills are more lightweight, compact, and designed for travel. Another great feature in the GMG model, which you have to consider when planning to take it with you on a camping trip, is the mini smoke sack located on one side of the grill.

Traeger grills aren’t meant to be portable. The dimensions of the Trager Pro 575 make this grill larger and unsuitable for travel. Due to the dual wheels, it is quite bulky, which means that it can be difficult to roll or transport from one place to another.

Green Mountain Grills vs. Traeger – Verdict

Both of these brands are well worth the investment.

If you are looking for a high-quality, lightweight, portable, and powerful pellet grill, GMG Davy Crocket is a front-runner.

But if your budget is without limits and you can comfortably buy a more expensive grill, the decision becomes harder and swings more towards the Traeger grills. The Traeger brand has an excellent lineup of high-quality premium grills, and Traeger Pro 575 is a perfect example.

The Battle Continues

It is up to you to decide which brand best suits your taste, needs, and budget. If you appreciate innovation, design, and an impressive set of features, Green Mountain Grill might be right for you. But if you just want a grill that is reliable and proven on the market, Traeger might be a better choice.

shares